Hallmark signed as many owners in one month as paid leads brought in five

Hallmark Property Management, running 404 doors in Oklahoma City, bought owner leads from a national directory to keep growth moving — but the leads were slow to convert, taking four to five months to sign three owners. Goodjuju took over the website and local SEO, tracking every lead source side by side on quarterly calls. On the April call, Hallmark's own numbers showed the website had signed three new owners in a single month — the same result the paid directory took four to five months to produce.
Challenge
Hallmark Property Management runs 404 doors in the Oklahoma City metro. Like a lot of property managers, they bought owner leads from a national directory to keep growth moving. The directory delivered volume, but the quality was rough and the conversions were slow — over four to five months, those paid leads produced three signed owners. Growth that depends on purchased leads has a ceiling, and Hallmark wanted their own presence, their website and their rankings, to become the engine instead.
Solution
Goodjuju took over the website and local SEO with one job: make Hallmark the property manager Oklahoma City owners find and contact on their own. Every lead source gets tracked side by side, so on each quarterly call both teams can compare the paid directory against the website on the numbers that matter — how many leads came in, how many were legitimate, and how many signed.
Results
On the April quarterly call, Brayden ran the comparison from his own lead tracking: the paid directory produced three signed owners in four to five months; the website produced three signed owners in the last month alone. April was the best lead month in Hallmark's tracking since the engagement began, and the company added seven doors and six to seven HOA communities this year while the organic engine ramps up. The end goal is to phase out the paid directory entirely once the website and SEO produce enough owner leads on their own.
We can definitely tell leads from APM are a lot worse. If we compare that to website leads, last month we had three signed. We currently manage 404 doors, and we've added seven new doors this year. We've also brought in six or seven HOAs. From leads, there's definitely been an uptick — April is definitely the best one.
Brayden, Hallmark Property Management


