Skip to main content
Shinesty/2025

From -23% to +10% YoY in 5 Months: How Adverio Rebuilt Shinesty's Amazon Operating System

From -23% to +10% YoY in 5 Months: How Adverio Rebuilt Shinesty's Amazon Operating System
-23%
YoY Unit Growth (Before)
+10%
YoY Unit Growth (After)
-14%
TACoS Reduction
+131% (from 0.30% baseline)
CTR Growth
+23% (from 5.64% baseline)
Unit Session % Improvement

When Adverio took over Shinesty's Amazon channel in September 2025, the brand was down 23% YoY heading into peak season. The problem wasn't advertising. It was structural: uncontrolled spend at the parent level, inventory and eligibility misalignment, no pricing recovery model, and a storefront showing ~40% YoY declines. In five months, Adverio rebuilt the operating system from the ground up. YoY units flipped from -23% to +10%, TACoS dropped 14%, CTR grew 131%, unit session percentage improved 23%, and refund rate fell 13%.

Challenge

Shinesty's Amazon channel had six compounding problems running at the same time. Prior-year stockouts had damaged organic rank. Pricing had no disciplined recovery methodology, leaving BSR exposed. Spend was not governed at the parent level, causing TACoS spikes without clear attribution. Inventory and ad eligibility were misaligned, meaning spend was running in places where conversion couldn't happen. The storefront was trending down roughly 40% YoY. And non-velocity driver SKUs were absorbing budget that should have been on margin drivers. Adding more ad spend into that structure would have accelerated the decline, not reversed it.

Solution

Adverio installed controls before touching budgets. TACoS guardrails were reset with a target band designed to achieve a 14% reduction. Branded waste was eliminated before any expansion was considered. Parent-level economics were corrected by reducing spend on non-velocity SKUs and realigning budget to contribution margin. Pricing was rebuilt as a structural recovery lever: controlled price drops to regain BSR, incremental raises on a defined cadence, and ASP anchored against prior-year levels. The inventory to eligibility to spend to conversion sequence was enforced as a hard flow model. On the conversion side, hero images were rebuilt with unique category-specific visuals, size clarity was improved to reduce fit mismatches, and PDP messaging was rewritten with conversion as the primary objective. Refund rate improvements followed directly from better buyer qualification and expectation alignment built into the listing itself.

Results

YoY unit growth moved from -23% to +10% in five months. TACoS reduced 14%. CTR grew 131% from a 0.30% baseline. Unit session percentage improved 23% from 5.64%. Refund rate dropped 13%. The recovery was structural, not a temporary ad spike driven by increased spend.

Why "More Ads" Would Have Made It Worse

The instinct when a brand is down 23% YoY is to spend more. More budget, more campaigns, more reach. That's the wrong diagnosis when the problem is structural. Shinesty's Amazon channel had broken sequencing: spend was running without inventory eligibility, pricing had no recovery logic, and parent-level economics were misaligned. Pouring more budget into that system would have widened the YoY gap, not closed it. Adverio's approach was to stop spending until the structure could support it, install the controls that were missing, and scale only after the foundation held. The 131% CTR improvement and 23% unit session gain came from fixing listings and images, not from increasing bids. The TACoS reduction came from governance, not cuts. That sequence is what made the recovery sustainable.

Project Details

Year

2025

Duration

5 months (ongoing from Sept 2025)

Live ProjectView →